AM: Re: Full-page force-feed advertising
> Hi all:
> I've very much enjoyed reading your discussions, which, as far as I
> can tell are a resounding vote against the full-screen,
> forced-advertising concept. Even so, it may be worth further
> exploration, as some form of that concept could possibly gain some
> steam as desperate advertisers experiment.
There definitely may be a place for full-page uninterruptible
It's just not prudent to make it a force-fed issue. (IMO)
In fact, I think folks would actually WELCOME such advertising if it's
truly fast in the downloading, and if the user has the CHOICE of viewing
A cultural barrier to any form of "push" technology exists on the Web
from the END USER Point of View. Advertisers who wish to reach these
people in the best possible mode have to respect that, and work with it.
Not "in your face" it.
> As some of you know, I'm a reporter/editor/researcher specializing in
> Internet topics. If any of you have any comments for me, I'd
> appreciate a note off list as to whether this topic is worth expanding
> into a story or not.
I think it definitely deserves a published story in the forum that folks
like Amon at IC have direct access to.
It's all well and good to have literature in a field that supportive of
the group that field represents, but if you get too vertical, and too
focused on the insider's POV, you're bound to miss what the outsider's
This is a story that needs to be told in traditional advertising
> Just because it seems like a bad idea doesn't mean that there aren't
> other issues worth researching...
Actually, it seems to me that discussion on what is wrong with an idea,
as long as it's not a "slamfest" has the definite potential for
suggesting new and workable solutions.
> Anne Zieger
I finished reading all the published information on the IC Web site.
The two founding members of IC seem to be approaching this strictly from
the traditional advertising medium POV. They seem to believe they can
mold the Web to traditional standards.
I think they're wrong, and >5 years of Web Advertising "lack of success"
stories would tend to verify that. The success stories cited for
Banners are questionable at best, and the sites that show measureable
increase in actual sales are almost exclusively passive in their
Passive in the sense that they let the customers choose to come in, not
dumping unsolicited commercial ads in the user's mail, with signifigant
TRADITIONAL marketing channels supplementing their WEB presence.
(Ex: Amazon.com has radio ads on most major stations, most corporations
are adding web-site information to their TV commercials.)
Jim Harmon The Telephone Connection
firstname.lastname@example.org Rockville, Maryland